home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94HT0027>
- <title>
- Feb. 9, 1970: Starting Down the Protest Trail
- </title>
- <history>Time-The Weekly Magazine-1970s Highlights</history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- The Angry American Indian: Starting Down the Protest Trail
- February 9, 1970
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> Most Americans know the first Americans only by cliche.
- There is the 19th century image, caught in bronze and in
- lithograph, of the defeated warrior, head drooping forward so
- that his feathers nearly mingle with his pony's mane. The bow
- of his shoulders and the slump of his body evoke his loss of
- pride, of green and fertile lands, of earth's most favored
- continent. Then there is the recent image, often seen through
- air-conditioned automobile windows. Grinning shyly, the fat
- squaw hawks her woven baskets along the reservation highway,
- the dusty landscape littered with rusting cars, crumbling
- wickiups and bony cattle. In the bleak villages, the only
- signs of cheer are romping, round-faced children, and the
- invariably dirty, crowded bar, noisy with the shouts and
- laughter of drunkenness.
- </p>
- <p> Like most stereotypes, these caricatures posses a certain
- core of validity. They also help white America contain and
- numb the reality of past guilt and present injustice. Most
- important of all, they are less and less significant. After
- more than a century of patience and passivity, the nation's
- most neglected and isolated minority is astir, seeking the
- means and the muscle for protest and redress. Sometimes highly
- educated, sometimes speaking with an articulateness forged of
- desperation, always angry, the new American Indian is fed up
- with the destitution and publicly sanctioned abuse of his
- long-divided people. He is raising his voice and he intends
- to be heard. Listen:
- </p>
- <p> "The next time whites try to illegally clear our land,
- perhaps we should get out and shoot the people in the
- bulldozers," contends Michael Benson, a 19-year-old Navajo and
- a freshman at Wesleyan University.
- </p>
- <p> "It's time that Indians got off their goddam asses and
- stopped letting white people lead them around by their noses,"
- says Lehman Brightman, a South Dakota Sioux now working on a
- PhD at Berkeley. "Even the name Indian is not ours. It was
- given to us by some dumb honky who got lost and thought he'd
- landed in India."
- </p>
- <p> "We weren't meant to be tourist attractions for the
- master race," scoffs Gerald Wilkinson, 30, a Cherokee who
- holds multiple degrees after attending four universities. "We
- don't use the language of the New Left, but that doesn't
- mean we're not militant."
- </p>
- <p> "Some day you're going to feel like Custer, baby,"
- shouted one unidentified Indian at Donald Dwyer, a former
- Minneapolis police officer recently invited to discuss city
- problems with a group of Minneapolis Indians.
- </p>
- <p>Symbolic Protest
- </p>
- <p> That kind of rhetoric is surprising, coming from people
- long since accustomed to equating silence with dignity. But
- in acts as well as speech, the newly aroused Indian is no
- longer content to play the obsequious Tonto to the white man's
- Lone Ranger. A belligerent band of 100 Indians still occupies
- the federal prison at Alcatraz, which the Indians propose to
- use as a cultural center and are willing to buy--for "$24 in
- glass beads and red cloth." Says one of the invaders:
- "Alcatraz is still better than most reservations." Angered at
- the whites who litter their beaches with beer cans and broken
- bottles, Indians in the state of Washington set up road blocks
- and closed 50 miles of seashore. A group of 50 Passamoquoddy
- Indians in Maine charged motorists fees to pass through their
- land on a busy highway last July. Four Indians at Dartmouth
- College, which was found partly "for civilizing and
- christianizing Children of Pagans," protested the Indian dress
- of the collage mascot, and officials banished it from football
- games.
- </p>
- <p> Going beyond such symbolic acts, Indians in Washington
- have deliberately violated fishing regulations that they
- consider a breach of their rights, and have gone to jail as
- a result. One of their leaders, Janet McCloud, a fiery
- Tulalip, contends that restrictions on catching salmon have
- reduced the Indian to "savages with no more rights than a
- bear." More softly, she concludes: "I don't like being a clown
- or a militant, but sometimes you have to break this conspiracy
- of silence." Another angry woman, Kahn Tineta Horn,
- effectively uses a trim figure in a tight buckskin dress to
- gain television attention for protest demonstrations. But sex
- is not her only weapon; she has been arrested for carrying a
- knife and for interfering with police.
- </p>
- <p> Harassment by police is the target of a sophisticated
- Indian uprising in Minneapolis, which has one of the few
- Indian ghettos in any city. There Clyde Bellecourt, 33, a
- tough Chippewa who has spent 14 years behind bars, has
- organized an "Indian Patrol." Dressed in red jackets, its
- members use short-wave radios to follow police activity, then
- show up to observe the cops silently whenever an Indian gets
- into trouble. After the patrol was formed, there were no
- arrests of Indians for 22 straight weekends. Ironically, it
- was during a prison term for burglary that Bellecourt decided
- he could help other Indians. "I read a lot of books," he says,
- "and I started finding out that I wasn't a savage, that I
- wasn't dirty--and that I was smart." For his work, he is paid
- a salary by the Urban Coalition.
- </p>
- <p> The new Indian activism is gradually beating its way into
- the nation's consciousness--and into its conscience. In was
- both salutary and shabby, Indians are becoming fashionable.
- As the New Yorker's Calvin Trillin recently observed: "It is
- almost possible to hear the drums in the East Sixties."
- </p>
- <p> The Indian is spicing his protest with a grim kind of
- humor. His slogans proclaim: KEMO SABE MEANS HONKY, RED
- POWER!, and CUSTER HAD IT COMING. More stingingly, Indian Folk
- Singer Buffy Sainte-Marie, a Cree with a degree in education
- and Oriental philosophy, confronts white audiences with
- pointed lyrics:
- </p>
- <list>
- <item> When a war between nations is lost
- <item> The loser, we know, pays the cost
- <item> But even when Germany fell to your hands
- <item> You left them their pride and you left them their land.
- </list>
- <p> The national abuse of the Indian reached Broadway last
- year as the subject of serious drama. Arthur Kopit's Indians
- played only twelve weeks; some critics considered it noisy,
- disorganized theater; some audiences seemed to find the
- penitential message discomfiting. A pro-Indian movie, Little
- Big Man, starring Dustin Hoffman, has been filmed on Montana's
- Crow reservation. It portrays George Custer as a villain
- leading troops bent on genocide. Three books personalizing
- Indian alienation have won critical acclaim. A novel, House
- Made of Dawn, by N. Scott Momaday, a Kiowa who teaches English
- at Berkeley, won a Pulitzer Prize last year. Custer Died for
- Your Sins, by Vine Deloria, a Standing Rock Sioux, wryly
- details the Indians' own infighting and their frustrations
- with white society. Our Brother's Keeper: The Indian in White
- America angrily indicts whites for keeping the Indian a
- stranger in his homeland--"America's prisoners of war."
- </p>
- <p> On the fad level, a budding renaissance of Indian
- cultural accouterments has inspired pot-smoking teenagers and
- high-fashion socialites to don beaded necklaces, fringed
- jackets, Indian belts, bikinis and feathers. Most Indians
- scoff at the affectation and claim that much of the clothing
- is foreign made.
- </p>
- <p>The Handicap of Dignity
- </p>
- <p> Why has it taken the Indian so long to rouse himself to
- turn his ire toward action? Many a white bureaucrat, ruling
- a reservation like a colonial army officer, has assumed that
- Indian acquiescence stemmed from either respect or servility.
- Rarely has it been either. The Indian nation was physically
- shattered and spiritually demoralized by the U.S. Cavalry,
- which systematically destroyed its leaders and the best of its
- manhood in the late 19th century campaigns that whites
- euphemistically call the pacification of the West. Long before
- the white man's arrival, Indian tribes had, of course, waged
- limited war upon one another of hunting rights, and raids for
- revenge were common.
- </p>
- <p> Yet on a personal level, Indian culture shuns
- confrontation. Even the meeting of eyes and the firm
- handshake were long avoided. Discussions of personal problems
- are painful. Indians have been known to sit in Government
- offices for hours before deciding to air a grievance, however
- just. "My mother won't even get rid of a salesman," says the
- Navajo's Michael Benson.
- </p>
- <p> For too long, Indian dissent also has been stifled by
- their forced dependency upon whites for land and livelihood.
- This has made many of them regard white authority as an almost
- magical thing. One veteran scholar of Arizona's Hopis, E.D.
- Newcomer, notes that today's young Hopis even "feel that the
- god of the whites must be better than their own gods, because
- the whites have new clothes and shiny cars."
- </p>
- <p> Handicapped by their special definition of dignity and
- fractionalized by their allegiances to about 300 tribes, the
- 652,000 Indians in the U.S. have never developed a unity that
- would sustain massive protest. (At the time of Columbus, the
- native population of what is now the U.S. was probably between
- 1,000,000 and 3,000,000. By 1860, that had dropped to about
- 340,000, and by 1910 to an all-time low of 220,000. No longer
- vanishing, the Indians are now the nation's fastest growing
- minority.) "Remember, I'm not an Indian, I'm Osage," declares
- Charles Lohah, an Oklahoma judge who finds political intrigue
- both within and among tribes fascinatingly complex. "Often we
- have to strap our shields to our backs," he says. But Indians
- have also watched the nation respond to the marches, sit-ins
- and street tactics of restive blacks. Indians feel little
- affinity with blacks, and there is friction between the races
- in some federal anti-poverty programs; still, the Indians are
- beginning to demand their share of the action.
- </p>
- <p> That demand is not only just but long overdue. Ford
- Foundation President McGeorge Bundy insists flatly that "the
- American Indians are by any measure save cultural heritage the
- country's most disadvantaged minority." After studying U.S.
- ill-treatment of the Indian 26 years ago, Swedish Socialist
- Gunnar Myrdal described it as "a morality play of profound
- importance" to American history. He said that it "challenges
- the most precious assumptions about what this country stands
- for--cultural pluralism, freedom of conscience and action, and
- the pursuit of happiness." The morality play is still a bad
- show today.
- </p>
- <p> The indicators of Indian suffering are appalling. Their
- life expectancy is 44 years, compared with 71 for white
- Americans. The average income for each Indian family living
- in a reservation--and more than half do--is only $1,500. The
- average years of schooling is 5.5 years, well behind that of
- both the black and the Mexican American. Some officials rate
- 90% of reservation housing as substandard. Unemployment ranges
- from a low of 20% on the more affluent reservations to 80% at
- the poorest. The birth rate of Indians is 2 1/2 times that of
- whites--and a majority of Indians are under 20 years old. The
- average family has to carry water for its daily needs at least
- a mile. It is usually done afoot.
- </p>
- <p> Indians, of course, are not statistics, and Time
- correspondent James Willwerth discovered that individual
- reality for Indians often consists of human deprivation in a
- setting of uplifting natural beauty. Visiting Arizona's White
- Mountain Apache reservation, he reported: "The land is like
- a painting--hills covered with ponderosa pine, snow-capped
- mountains in the distance, sprawling valleys filled with thick
- forests and rushing streams. In the midst of all this, there's
- a one-room shack with a corrugated metal roof that shows
- daylight from every angle. This is Judy's house. Judy is in
- her mid-20s, stocky but not fat, and rather pretty. But she
- drinks a lot, gets into fights when she does, and often ends
- up in jail.
- </p>
- <p> "Her lovers are legion. The result of one liaison toddles
- toward me through broken glass and excrement. He's less than
- two years old. He lived with Judy's sister until recently, but
- Judy took him back to get some welfare money. Now they are
- living in this one-room place. 'It's got no windows,' she
- says. 'But that's nothing. I've never lived in a house with
- windows.'"
- </p>
- <p> The grim individual vignettes are multiplied among
- entire tribes. In northern Arizona, twelve small villages of
- the deeply religious Hopis fight their uncertain struggle to
- avoid extinction. Reversing years of decline, the Hopis now
- number 6,000. Isolated for centuries, even their own villages
- still have no political links with one another. They live on
- three massive sandstone mesas in the Painted Desert, where
- pasture land is scarce and only their skillful dry-farming of
- corn provides a meager diet.
- </p>
- <p> The sole tribal commerce of the Hopis is a trailer court
- and a few arts-and-crafts shops. Yet the hope of the Hopis
- lies in their determination to improve their condition. They
- teach their children to value schooling so highly that the
- average daily attendance in their elementary schools is a
- surprising 90%--a rarity among Indians. A score of older
- youngsters take a bus each day and make a 96-mile round trip
- to attend high school. Each day 50 adult Hopis get up at 5
- a.m. to board a yellow bus and ride 65 miles to their jobs at
- a BVD underwear plant. Things may get better. Coal has been
- found on Hopi land, and a strip mine is scheduled to open this
- year. Ironically the Hopi devotion to education is diluting
- what they value most; their own special kind of polytheistic
- belief that each living thing possesses a human spirit. Now,
- when elders hold their annual dance with rattlesnakes, many
- Hopi children laugh.
- </p>
- <p>Agony and Anomie
- </p>
- <p> To live in squalor while surrounded by beauty, to desire
- a better material life while clinging to tradition is, for
- American Indians to know agony and anomie. Their alienation
- is aggravated by the fact that Indian culture is vastly
- different from that of whites in terms of technology,
- productivity and intellectual interests. From the viewpoint
- of what makes a modern civilization work, Indian culture
- appears hopelessly irrelevant. To some extent, the collision
- of Western and Indian cultures warped the conquerors'
- attitudes. When the Senecas sought assurances from President
- Thomas Jefferson in 1802 that their rights would be
- protected, no attempt was made to bridge the cultural gap.
- They received a patronizing note from a secretary that said:
- "Brothers, your father, the President, will at all times be
- your friend and he will protect you and all his red children
- from bad people." Only last fall Ted Rushton of New Mexico's
- Gallup Independent wrote haughtily of "the inevitable clash
- of a superior culture with a vastly inferior culture."
- </p>
- <p> The Indian child who attends school with whites must
- brace himself for taunts: when it rains, he is told, "You must
- have done your dance." If he has a girl friend, he is asked
- "How's your squaw?" It it my be "Hey Tonto, where's your
- horse?" and "What number is your teepee?" "Indian kids are
- shy, and can't take this," explains Gary Fife, 19, an Oklahoma
- Cherokee-Creek student at Northeastern State College.
- </p>
- <p> Prejudice is as painful a fact to Indians as it is to
- blacks. Indians suffer just as harshly from biased history
- books. One text observes that "it is probably true that all
- the American tribes in the course of their wandering lived for
- some generations on the frozen wastes of Alaska. This
- experience deadened their minds and killed their imagination
- and initiative. A white teacher in a Chippewa reservation
- school recently asked Indian children to write essays on "Why
- we are all happy the Pilgrims landed." Western movies and
- television, of course, still portray the Indian as the savage
- marauder. "How are you going to expect the Indian to feel a
- part of America when every television program shows him to be
- a brute or a stupid animal? asks Ray Fadden, owner of a Mohawk
- museum in northern New York. On a Apache reservation, even an
- Indian girl was caught up in the TV drama. As an Indian actor
- crept up on an unsuspecting cowboy, the girl involuntarily
- shouted at the cowboy: "Get him! Get him!"
- </p>
- <p> Indians smolder when the white operators of trading posts
- sell their Indian-crafted goods to tourists at 400% mark-ups.
- They resent the white sportsmen who gun down caribou from
- airplanes, while their own hunting for lifesaving game is
- restricted by white laws. They become furious at the white
- shopkeepers' use of Indian religious symbols and bad portraits
- of Indian chiefs. Don Wilkerson, the Cherokee-Creek director
- of the Phoenix Indian Center, claims that a bar in Scottsdale,
- Ariz., has a huge picture of a great Indian chief on its roof
- as an advertising gimmick. "The Jewish people would not permit
- such treatment of one of their revered leaders," he says. "Nor
- would society allow Martin Luther King to be so humiliated."
- </p>
- <p>Alcoholism and Suicide
- </p>
- <p> Dispirited by poverty, rejected by a white culture in
- which they are often unable and unwilling to compete, many
- Indians choose death or drink. The suicide rate among Indian
- teen-agers is three times the national average; on some
- reservations it is ten times as high. Shattered by her
- parents' broken marriage, an 18-year-old Blackfoot girl not
- long ago killed herself on her Montana reservation with an
- overdose of tranquilizers, though she was an honor student.
- Accused of drinking during school hours, a 16-year-old youth
- on Idaho's Fort Hill Reservation hanged himself in the county
- jail. Just two days before, he had talked about conditions on
- the reservation with Senator Robert F. Kennedy.
- </p>
- <p> Alcohol has long been a means of escape from boredom and
- pressures for Indians. On one Midwest reservation containing
- 4,600 adults, 44% of all the men and 21% of the women were
- arrested at least once for drunkenness in a span of three
- years. Many reservations have opened bars and liquor stores
- to keep Indians from killing themselves in auto accidents en
- route home from binges in the city. A much-repeated
- explanation quotes Bill Pensoneau, president of the National
- Indian Youth Council, as telling a new Commissioner of Indian
- Affairs: "We drown ourselves in wine and smother ourselves in
- glue--because the only time we are free is when we're drunk.
- </p>
- <p>The Paternalistic BIA
- </p>
- <p> Sober or drunk, most Indians cite the Bureau of Indian
- Affairs when they lament their troubles. A unit of the
- Interior Department, it is supposed to help all native
- Americans under federal jurisdiction to achieve a better life,
- mainly by offering education and medical care and protecting
- their land, water and other treaty rights. More often, it
- suffocates Indians with its all-encompassing paternalistic
- authority. An Indian must have BIA permission to sell his
- land; he is taught by BIA teachers, and if he cannot support
- his children they may be taken from his home by the BIA and
- placed in boarding schools or with white foster parents. Most
- BIA employees are white.
- </p>
- <p> The first Indian head of the BIA in this century was
- Robert Bennett, appointed by President Johnson in 1966, and
- admired by most moderate Indian leaders. An Oneida from
- Wisconsin and a career BIA man, Bennett resigned in dismay
- last July, charging that "the new Administration has
- completely ignored the Indians." His successor is Louis Bruce,
- part Mohawk and part Oglala Sioux, who seems just as
- frustrated as his people in dealing with the Great White
- Father. "I keep hearing terrible and sad things that are
- happening that I don't know about." One trouble with the
- bureau, claims one of its most effective field men, is that
- it is overstaffed at top levels (there is one BIA employee for
- every 18 Indians), and it takes three years to get new funds
- to pave a road. "We have created a monster," he says.
- </p>
- <p> Indians have seen countless treaties broken, their lands
- diminished from 138 million acres in 1887 to 55 million acres
- today, their water diverted. They are convinced that the
- Government is determined eventually to dismiss the whole
- problem by terminating all reservations. Long a favorite white
- liberal policy, based on the assumption that all minorities
- will thrive by being assimilated into the mystical American
- melting pot, termination of the reservations is now heatedly
- rejected by nearly all Indian leaders. These Indians now want
- first to conserve all that is best of their own heritage,
- summed up in the slogan INTEGRITY, NOT INTEGRATION. They are
- thus moving in tandem with black groups that have rejected
- integration in favor of black power. Theoretically, at least,
- Indians have several advantages over the blacks in moving
- toward their goals. They have available a whole federal
- bureaucracy that professes to want the same end. While they
- lack national unity, their tribal traditions give them a sense
- of self-identity. And above all, they have their own lands.
- (The first reservation opened in 1853, and the system still
- includes some 284 BIA-supervised enclaves. Indians are free
- to leave reservations whenever they wish, but those who do not
- live on them do not benefit from most Indian-aid programs. All
- Indians were granted full citizenship status in 1924.)
- </p>
- <p>To Keep the Land
- </p>
- <p> The fight to preserve those lands and the water required
- to make their acreage livable is a constant one for U.S.
- Indians. The Senecas are still bitter about the 10,000 acres
- taken in 1964 by the Army Corps of Engineers for the Kinuza
- Dam. The Senecas were paid $3,000,000, but to them land is no
- mere matter of money--it is a spiritual as well as a
- sustaining resource. The Tuscaroras of New York lost 553 acres
- to a reservoir in the late 1950s. They were paid $850,000,
- only to learn that nearby Niagara University got $5,000,000
- for just 200 acres.
- </p>
- <p> Currently, Indians in New Mexico, Montana and California
- are locked in battles with various Government agencies for
- control of land and water. The Paiutes of western Nevada have
- watched their emerald-green Pyramid Lake, ancient source of
- their cutthroat trout, shrink to one-third its former size by
- various water-diversion projects. The lake's ecological
- balance has been destroyed, and most of the fish have died.
- </p>
- <p> The most dramatic controversy over native lands is one
- now raging over the ownership of 90% of the acreage of Alaska.
- Aided by some of the nation's best lawyers, including some of
- the nation's best lawyers, including former Supreme Court
- Justice Arthur Goldberg and former Attorney General Ramsay
- Clark, 55,000 Indians, Eskimos and Aleuts contend that they
- hold title to the Alaskan land because the U.S. did not
- purchase it from Russia in 1867; it bought only the right to
- tax and govern the territory. When Alaska became a state in
- 1959, the state began to assert claim to the area. It has
- seized 450,000 acres for itself. The natives are willing to
- give up all except 40 million acres--10% of the state--at a
- price of $500 million and a 2% royalty in revenues from the
- surrendered lands. If they do not get satisfaction this time,
- the native groups calculate that they have sufficient legal
- options to tie up the land in court contests for years.
- </p>
- <p> Today activist Indians throughout the U.S. are determined
- to push all such holding operations to the limit of their
- resources, since they have seen the devastating impact of
- closed-down reservations. The Menominees of Wisconsin had good
- schools and community services, plus a sawmill owned by the
- tribe, when they were "terminated" in 1961. Since then many
- Menominees have had to sell their lands to pay taxes in their
- new ownership status. The Indian hospital shut down and
- sawmill profits dwindled. As a result, the state paid out more
- than six times as much money in welfare to the Menominees as
- before--and the Menominees lost their identity. "The Menominee
- tribe is dead," reports Professor Gary Orfield in a study for
- the University of Chicago, "but for no good reason." Also
- terminated in 1961, Oregon's Klamath tribe suffered soaring
- rates of suicides, crime and drunkenness.
- </p>
- <p> There are, however, encouraging signs of progress in some
- reservations. The Lummi tribe of Washington State, a sea-
- oriented people along Puget Sound, are using federal funds and
- considerable hard labor to develop the most advanced aquafarm
- in the U.S. They control the spawning and cultivating of
- oysters, the breeding of hybrid steelhead-rainbow trout and
- the harvesting of algae, used in making toothpaste, ice cream
- and pudding. It may net $1,000 an acre for the Indians,
- compared with at most $40 an acre in land farming.
- </p>
- <p> Elsewhere some 150 commercial and industrial enterprises,
- among them General Dynamics and Fairchild Camera, have moved
- onto Indian reservations, enticed by the freedom from real
- estate taxes accorded reservation enterprises--and by cheap
- labor. They provide jobs and profits for individual Indians
- as well as their tribes. Simpson Cox, a white Phoenix lawyer,
- has spent 22 years with the Gila River Pima-Maricopa Indians,
- successfully pressing the government to compensate the tribe
- fairly for confiscating their lands. He has helped them build
- industrial parks, a tourist center, a trade school, farms,
- community centers and an airstrip.
- </p>
- <p> Antipoverty funds are also beginning to benefit Indians,
- since by any definition no group in the U.S. is more
- impoverished than Indians. One group utilizing such funds is
- Oklahoma for Indian Opportunity, founded by LaDonna Harris,
- the attractive, mixed-blood Comanche wife of Senator Fred
- Harris, chairman of the Democratic National Committee. Her
- group fights federal red tape to help reservation Indian,
- gathers evidence when whites discriminate against them, forms
- buying clubs to combat high grocery prices, trains young
- Indians for jobs and leadership. There are sharp contrasts in
- the efforts to help reservation Indians. Navajos at their
- tribal headquarters in Window Rock, Ariz., have eagerly taken
- to instruction in the use of a computer to handle industrial-
- development projects. In northern Minnesota, Indians had
- strayed so far from their traditions that white sportsmen had
- to be employed to teach them the rudiments of canoeing, water
- safety and fishing.
- </p>
- <p>Life in the City
- </p>
- <p> Indians also now have a few influential voices in the
- U.S. Congress. One of them belongs to Senator Edward Kennedy,
- whose subcommittee on Indian education recently charged that
- "our nation's policies and programs for educating American
- Indians are a national tragedy." Another friend is Minnesota
- Senator Walter Mondale. An honorary Chippewa chief, Mondale
- criticizes Indian schools as containing the elements of
- disaster. "The first thing an Indian learns is that he is a
- loser."
- </p>
- <p> The Indians who move off the land and into big cities are
- indeed apt to become losers. More than 200,000 Indians have
- done so. They do not congregate as closely as blacks, partly
- because they meet less resistance in moving into low-income
- white neighborhoods. There are nearly 60,000 in Los Angeles,
- perhaps 20,000 in the San Francisco Bay area, about 12,000 in
- Phoenix, 15,000 on Chicago's North Side. Some 12,000 inhabit
- the Minneapolis-St. Paul area, almost half in shabby apartment
- houses and creaky Victorian houses near Minneapolis' Franklin
- Avenue, which cops and Indians alike call "the reservation."
- </p>
- <p> Time Correspondent Richard Saltonstall talked to many
- Indians who had tried the urban life. "Nobody mistreated me
- in Dallas," he was told by Donna Flood, a mixed-blood Ponca.
- "But I was unhappy there. It was too fast. There was noise,
- fumes, confusion--the white man's problems. In the city you
- lose your contact and feeling for the land. You become
- isolated." Hiner Doublehead, a Cherokee with two children,
- took his family to Chicago. "God, it was a jungle when we got
- there," he recalled. "The people lived like foreigners--
- unfriendly, clannish. It was the closeness and the crammed-in
- living that got to me. The bars were the only places to get
- acquainted and to unwind. But the friendships never went far.
- Nobody would invite you up to his house. I didn't feel like
- I was human up there."
- </p>
- <p> Even the Indians who manage to make it often get restless
- and long to return to their reservation families for
- spiritual renewal. many do so, abruptly abandoning jobs. It
- is the lure of the land, most often, that proves irresistible.
- "They used to tell me that the land is like your mother,"
- explains Tom Cook, a 21-year-old Mohawk. "The trees are your
- brothers, as are the birds in the air and the fish in the
- water. They give you life; they give you food; they give you
- everything. It was so pretty the way my grandmother used to
- tell it." Cook attends college in New York City and is a full-
- time steelworker in Manhattan.
- </p>
- <p>Something of Value
- </p>
- <p> Indian grievances are specific, but the goals of redress
- so far remain diffuse. There are no Indian leaders who, with
- any confidence of national support from their people, can
- speak on precisely what should be done. Traditionalists merely
- tend to look at the mountains that have sheltered their tribes
- for centuries and at the writings of their ancestral prophets.
- and they say patiently: "We'll outlast you whites." There are
- others who seek accommodation of white and Indian cultures.
- Says Ronnie Lupe, tribal chairman of the White Mountain
- Apaches: "We know what the white man offers us. There are
- certain comforts in your culture--good homes, good cars, good
- jobs--but there is a certain want to get these and yet retain
- our identity, and we have yet to find it."
- </p>
- <p> But even that kind of reasonableness is dismissed by the
- new Indian militants as the talk of "Uncle Tom-Toms" or "Uncle
- Tomahawks" and "Stand-Around-the-Fort Indians." What these
- leaders seem to want most is for the Federal Government, which
- now spends only $500 million a year on aid to Indians, to
- increase its spending for Indian schools, roads, housing and
- medical care--and to stop smothering Indians with restrictive
- regulations and unwanted advice on how to run their affairs.
- They want their water and land rights protected and expanded,
- not contracted through treaty violations. They want help in
- attracting job-providing industries to their reservations, but
- they want to determine what kinds and how they will be
- operated. They want federal benevolence, in short, as
- compensation for the loss of more than half a continent, but
- they want to be free to go their own way--even though they are
- not yet certain of their direction.
- </p>
- <p> The Indians' longing to live harmoniously with nature
- touches recesses of nostalgia in the minds of many Americans.
- Indeed, at a time when the drive to protect and restore the
- nation's physical environment is the most popular cause of the
- day, whites' guilt over their spoilage of air, land and water
- engenders a new admiration for those who have fought for so
- long to protect their own plains, lakes and hunting grounds.
- It would be wrong to romanticize Indian culture, but there is
- something to be valued, or at least envied, in a society that
- respects the wisdom of elders, enjoys the closeness of
- kinship, prefers tranquility to competition, and sees little
- merit n 9-to-5 punctuality at a desk.
- </p>
- <p> Although they now live in what one Indian calls "a
- schizoid world of featured loyalties," all Indian leaders
- agree that the best of their ancient heritage is a priceless
- resource. To many white Americans, who are constantly told
- these days how much they have to feel guilty about, the
- demands of yet one more minority may seem almost more than the
- conscience can bear. Yet Indians can hardly be expected to
- keep their peace just because they have only lately joined
- the queue of those vociferously demanding social justice. If
- they continue to be rejected, many young Indians will continue
- to despair and will embrace the sentiments of Phil George, a
- young Nez Perce, who wrote:
- </p>
- <list>
- <item> This summer I shall
- <item> Return to our Longhouse,
- <item> Hide beneath a feathered hat,
- <item> And become an Old Man.
- </list>
- <p> The new militants reject such resignation, and are
- determined that Indians be heard along with all of America's
- second-class citizens. Their aim is nothing less than to
- reverse the perspectives of the races. Explains one:
- </p>
- <p> "You will forgive me if I tell you that my people were
- Americans for thousands of years before your people were. The
- question is not how you can Americanize us but how we can
- Americanize you. The first thing we want to teach you is that,
- in the American way of life, each man has respect for his
- brother's vision. Because each of us respected his brother's
- dream, we enjoyed freedom here while your people were busy
- killing and enslaving one another across the water. We have
- a hard trail ahead of us, but we are not afraid of hard
- trails."
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-